Questions? Call Us: 800.228.4718
Close
(0) items
You have no items in your shopping cart.
All Categories
    Filters
    Preferences
    Search
    Filter your results
    Manufacturers

    Flappers

    Toilet tank flappers

    New York Replacement Parts stocks hundreds of toilet tank flappers from all the major toilet manufacturers. We carry toilet flappers in many different styles for all one piece and two piece toilets. Replace your toilet tank flapper today and get your toilets working efficiently again.

    There are many different signs that your toilet flapper needs replacing some of which include your toilet constantly running, your toilet turning itself on and filling up every few minutes. Cold water after time can cause the flapper to shrink and bend the edges up. If you touch the flapper and it is sticky the flapper is deteriorating. You should replace your toilet flapper if any of these conditions occur.

    Toilet flappers in stock now for immediate shipping.

    View as Grid List
    Sort by
    Display per page
    162 products found.

    Delta RP72472 Flapper (ABS And Rubber Gasket)

    $13.75 $18.35
    ABS And Rubber Gasket Flapper

    Kohler GP1067183 Flapper - Class 5

    $8.39 $11.99
    Class 5 Flapper

    CRANE P030750000 FLAPPER

    $5.41 $6.36
    FLAPPER

    MANSFIELD 630-0207 3" FLAPPER

    $6.81
    3" FLAPPER

    Fluidmaster 5104 Flapper Chain

    $1.48 $1.97
    Flapper Chain

    Fluidmaster 500 Universal Toilet Flapper

    $2.25 $2.99
    Universal Toilet Flapper

    Fluidmaster 504 Universal Long LIfeToilet Flapper

    $3.64 $4.85
    Universal Long LIfeToilet Flapper

    MANSFIELD 228 HB Flapper

    $9.19 $12.25
    HB Flapper

    ELJER 495-6049-00 FLAPPER & CHAIN

    $3.28 $3.86
    FLAPPER & CAHIN

    ELJER 495-6072-00 FLAPPER & CHAIN

    $5.80 $6.82
    FLAPPER & CHAIN

    Korky 57BP Crane Flapper 57BP

    $2.59 $2.99
    Fits Crane Flapper 57BP

    Korky 525BP Universal Replacement Flapper

    $5.50
    Universal Replacement Flapper

    Crane P030755000 Flapper "Discontinued"

    $2.55 $3.00
    Toilet Flapper

    ELJER 495-6070-00 FLAPPER

    $7.85 $9.24
    FLAPPER

    Korky 61BP Eljer Replacement Flapper 61BP

    $2.69 $2.99
    Fits Eljer Replacement Flapper 61BP

    ELJER 495-6061-00 FLAPPER

    $3.74 $4.40
    FLAPPER

    Eljer 490-6512-00 Touch Flush Kit

    $12.13 $13.98
    Touch Flush Kit

    Korky 58BP Kohler Flush Ball #58bp

    $2.79 $3.09
    Fits Kohler Flush Ball #58bp

    FLUIDMASTER 5085 FLUSH Flapper (FITS KOHLER Models)

    $4.71 $6.28
    5085 FLUSH Flapper (FITS KOHLER Models)

    Sterling 1105825 Flapper With Float Kit

    $5.95 $7.90
    Flapper With Float Kit

    Fluidmaster 5084 Rialto Toilet Flaper (Fits Kohler 1piece models)

    $3.35 $4.47
    Rialto Toilet Flaper (Fits Kohler 1piece models)

    Fluidmaster 5051 FLAPPER

    $4.76 $6.34
    5051 Universal Water Saving Long Lasting Toilet Flapper

    Fluidmaster 5082 Shark Fin Flapper (fits Kohler models)

    $3.35 $4.47
    Shark Fin Flapper (fits Kohler models)